G-Ramps - Curiosity Driven Natural Mastery of AI

A platform that helps you naturally become a "non-PhD" AI researcher, where curiosity is the only prerequisite.

Note:- Whatever motivation I mention to propose new teaching style may be not totally correct but definitely most of the parts are correct. I will change it in later version, if I find the need for it. But I am very much confident and excited about the new teaching style. It will be useful to broad audience regardless of what motivation inspired it.

Also, this blog is in draft version currently and you will find grammar mistakes, which I will be fixing in later versions.

Introduction

There are many mountains with different level of difficulty to climb. Mount everest is the tallest mountain but it is not the difficult mountain to climb. Apparently, K2 is the most difficult mountain. Difficulty of climbling a mountain is due to multiple factors includng altitude, weather, avalanches, route complexity e.g. steeper route, and available supports like guides, fixed ropes, oxygen etc.

Let’s consider an analogy of climbing mountains where we are assuming that all people have great mountaineer inside them. In the analogy with mountain and mountaineering, we are comparing mountains to any topic or subject which can be learned. Successfully climbing a mountain means deeply understand or mastering a topic. AI algorithms are like difficult mountains in the sense that efforts to master them is many fold times the other “not so difficult” topics. We all are intelligent just like a great mountaineer inside all of us. Students who are just “curious” to master AI are just like those people who want to summit difficult mountains and want to be confident enough, so to be able to summit any difficult mountain.

All can summit any difficult mountain successfully only if they unveil great mountaineer inside them by realising it. There is exponential distribution. As one moves towards greater amount of realisation, number of people with that amount of realisation exponentially decreases. There are exponentially more people who have not realised it much than people who have realised it to greater amount. Out of all curious people, very few realises fully that they have a great mountaineer inside them. Rest of the people only partially realises it to different extent but do not fully realise it.

To climb any difficult mountains, one may or may not first train themselves either formally via courses or informally by first climbing easier mountains. One may or may not have to first put required efforts in training before they can climb any difficult mountain. The very few ones who fully realises, they can directly climb any difficult mountain successfully without going through any training. They can learn mountaineering skill while directly climbing on difficult mountains. Once they learn skills, then they will be able to summit any difficult mountain relatively easy. But they will learn in unstructured manner, so it will take some time before they can learn all mountaineering skills. So, they will go through proper training so that they can learn skills in a structured manner and hence in less time. Majority of the people who do not realises fully have to go through training first. So that they can fully realise after learning mountaineering skills. Full realisation is necessary before one can attempt to climb any difficult mountain because it is a matter of life and death. And one do not want to be in doubt while climbing difficult mountain that whether they can successfully summit or not. Doubt may interfere with their mental state and may let them take more time than needed to climb the mountain, which in turn make their physical health more worse.

The one who fully realises, they will be able to go through training very naturally, which is nothing but they are able to put required efforts for training effortlessly.

The ones who do not fully realises won’t be able to put efforts effortlessly, i.e. they won’t train naturally. Because they are not sure whether they will be able to put all required efforts. Because they are only curious about climbing difficult mountains and they are not sure that training will unveil great mountaineer inside them and hence let them climb any difficult mountains. While training, one is away from difficult mountains and its condition. There will be a doubt factor that whether they will be able to satisfy their curiosity of climbing any difficult mountain or not. And because of this, there curiosity may also drop and which will create further doubt that whether they will be able to put required efforts for training or not. Because of all this doubt, one will constantly think why to put efforts, if it is not fruitful or does not satisfy curiosity. Doubt will not let you put required efforts effortlessly. It will try you to stop putting efforts. Training is like you want to move forward but against some force. Different people will have different level of doubt factor. More the doubt factor, less efforts can be put effortlessly. And therefore they will put different percentages of required efforts effortlessly depending on their doubt factor.

Very few will be able to put all the required efforts and fully realise. Hence, they will be able to manifest successfully that they are great mountaineer by summiting enough difficult mountains. Very few because majority of people have very little or no realisation, so they will be moving against a large force. So only very very few people will be able to sustain it and put required efforts. We are considering this because we have to consider exceptions who can sustain against large force. And very very few people will move against very little force because they have more amount of realisation, so they will be able to sustain it easily and hence put required efforts. Majority of people won’t be able to sustain and put all the required efforts. Depending on at what point they give up, they will be considered as dreamer, or as average mountaineer, or as an above-average mountaineer but not great mountaineer.

Training was supposed to fully realise those who didn’t fully realised yet. But since training process is not natural, only the ones who already fully realised are able to complete successfully and also those rare people who are able to sustain effortfulness. Shouldn’t curiosity be the only prerequisite to become great mountaineer? And able to climb any difficult mountain shouldn’t be just for those people who already fully realised. It should be for everyone who are curious.

For curiosity be the only prerequisite, one have to make the process of realisation natural. A person should feel like he/she should be able to put all required efforts and there shouldn’t be any doubt factor. Then only putting efforts will be effortless.

Why naturalness? So that anyone who is curious, moves forward without any force against them, so that they will be able to move forward successfully without anyone giving up in between. And those giving up are the only ones who didn’t want to move forward at the first place and were not curious at all.

If there were “help” which include stairs to the summit of a difficult mountain with overall bearable environment till summit, then anyone who wants to summit (the “curious” ones) will be able to summit. Because they are curious to climb a difficult mountain and by looking at stairs and bearable environment till summit, they will think they can definitely put the required efforts because it will satisfy their curiosity successfully. Since there is no doubt factor, they will be able to put required efforts effortlessly. Hence now it is natural for them to climb the difficult mountain.

Once they successfully summit, they would immediately know that they could have done it naturally with lesser help i.e. with more steep stairs and less bearable environment. And once they try with lesser help, they would again think that they could have done with even less help and so on. Slowly, they would realise their potential that they can climb naturally with lesser and lesser help. And eventually after enough summits with lesser and lesser help, they will fully realise that they have a great mountaineer inside them and they don’t require help at all.

There is very similar situation in AI. In this blog, we will talk about similar “help” but for mastering AI. Help in the context of AI has the same philosophy. It will be for all curious people and process of mastering will be natural. We will be calling the help “G-Ramps”. It is the potential way through which any curious student can naturally become a non-PhD “great” AI researcher where only prerequisite is curiosity or enthusiasm or excitement. One do not need to be intelligent or should be good at required maths. Intelligence is a state which currently-not-so intelligent student can reach to with experience given that they already have enough curiosity.

Outline of the blog

g-ramps blog outline

We will first talk about who is our audience. Then we will talk about our goal. Then we will be defining some terms like “AI”, “AI Mastery” and “Learning Resources” for this blog. Then we will talk about how a learner gonna learn and explain in detail the situation we are dealing with. Then we will start to deal with the situation. And at last, we will propose the detailed way and will explain in detail how it will deal with the situation successfully.

[talk about the abstractness of the blog]

Learners

Let’s first talk about who is our audience. Our audience is anyone who is curious to master AI and become great AI researcher. We will be calling such curious people “learners” in this blog. For this blog, “mastering AI” or becoming a “great AI researcher” is same thing and will be used interchangeably.

What I strongly believe is that intelligence is a state and all human beings can become intelligent if they are already not in that state. Some people are born intelligent and some become intelligent over time. There are definitely no binary states of “intelligent” and “not-intelligent” but a continuum over many states. For simplicity, let’s divide the continuum in two sets of states. First set contain single state which is “intelligent” and second set contain rest of the states of continuum. Meaning second set contain states from “not-intelligent” to having little intelligence to close to being an intelligent but not intelligent. Let’s name the learners falling in the first set “X” and those falling in second set “Y”. X learners are those who join the top PhD programmes and becomes great researchers. Trajectory of Y learners varies, some give up after trying and some become average AI researcher after a lot of struggle and very few become great AI researcher after transitoning to a “intelligent” state.

What I mean by intelligence here (which I may be wrong about, if so, I will change the description but for now, let’s go with this). Instead of defining it, which is difficult, let me mention how it manifests, which should be fine for this blog.

The way it manifests in X learners is that they can learn anything naturally, even if there is very little curiosity for it. Learning naturally means able to put the required efforts effortlessly. Because they know for sure their efforts won’t go to waste, i.e. they will master successfully because either they have good knowledge base by learning similar things. Or they just enjoy being in deep focus state therefore they just pour themselves in effortlessly without caring about the result. They just enjoy putting the efforts which in turn let them put the required efforts effortlessly. After putting the required efforts, they will come out of it either mastering the topic or confidently coming with a conclusion that this topic is arbitrary and can not be derived logically and hence can not be learned. Overall, they are able to invest themselves effortlessly because either they know they will get return or they just simply enjoy in being invested or they have both - good knowledge base and deep focus ability.

Y learners can not learn anything naturally. They can only learn naturally when there is enough curiosity for a topic, i.e., it should be more than required efforts. They have only curiosity to drive them to learn naturally. If curiosity is more than required efforts then there is no doubt factor that whether they will be able to put all required efforts or not. And hence they will be able to put efforts effortlessly. Because they know their curiosity will drive them to put all required efforts.

Otherwise if there is no enough curiosity i.e. required efforts for a topic is more than their curiosity for that topic, then putting efforts will feel effortful. Why not enough curiosity? This could happen in two ways. In one way, curiosity is high but estimated required efforts seem so much more than curiosity. In other way, a learner’s curiosity just drops low because it is not getting satisfied right way and also they may not be sure whether it is ever going to satisfy or not.

Why feels effortful when there is no enough curiosity? Because they are in doubt whether there efforts will be worthwhile in terms of whether they will be able to satisfy their original curiosity of mastering or not. They are in doubt because for reasons explained in previous paragraph, there is no enough curiosity to drive them to put all required efforts. They are not sure whether they will be able to put required efforts before giving up to short-term fun. If they couldn’t put required efforts and give up early then whatever efforts they have already put will go to waste, because they could not satisfy their curiosity of mastering. They are continuously doubting whether their investment of efforts, is worthwhile or not. They are not all in, in terms of their mental capacity. There is a force against what they have to do. It feels effortful because they need to go against this doubt factor or feeling of giving up and do something else which is doable. Because of this effortfulness, they may feel stuck, or may take long time or some may are able to easily give up that topic for some other interesting stuff which they know will give instant gratification.

What I mean by putting efforts? Anything there is to learn can be framed as problem-solution pair. We all humans have innate problem solving skill. Curiosity to learn something drives us to use this skill. Using this skill is what I meant by putting efforts.

Learners are those people who want to become great AI researchers, so either they want to join top PhD programs or just want to become a “non-PhD” AI researcher.

There are very few learners who will be able to join PhD program, not to mention top PhD programs. Simple reason is that there are just too many learners and there are not as many seats across the world because of limited funding, limited professors etc. So, therefore a good PhD programs requires a good profile as a prerequisite for screening which includes good academic record with good mathematics, research projects etc. As explained above, X learners are ideal candidates for PhD because they will most probably have good academic record and they will also be able to create good research profile and will be able to meet other requirements. X learners will think that these PhD programs are for them only. If they do not get in one cycle, they will keep trying and they will be able to join it. Many of the Y learners who thought to join a PhD program won’t be able to join when they come to know about difficult requirement. Either they won’t have good academic record. Or even if they have, they would just won’t be sure that they will be able to build good research projects so to be able to compete at the global level, so they won’t be able to build good research projects naturally. Except for few exceptional Y learners who will be able to put required efforts effortfully, many Y learners just will give up and won’t be able to join a PhD program.

Rest of the learners which are majority of the learners will try to become “non-PhD” AI researchers because they are still curious and want to satisfy their curiosity by still trying to master AI and become an AI researcher. They either want to be independent AI researchers (not affiliated with university or any company) or want to do research in a company. Even if they do not able to publish papers because of its cost, but they will be able to write high quality papers publishable at top conferences. That is, they will atleast be able to improve or create novel algorithms so that they can use those algorithms to solve new problems or solve existing problems in better way at their company.

All these learners are Y learners except for few X learners. Some are those Y learners who wanted to join a PhD program but couldn’t join it as explained in previous para. Others are those X and Y learners who do not want to join a PhD program at the first place. These are learners who are either in a developing or under developed country and do not want to get into financial burden by moving to expensive city in a new country or just can’t leave the country. Or they are in a school or undergrad college. Or can’t go away from home. Or because of age. Or a X learner who can’t find appropriate PhD programme. Because of these reasons, or for some other reasons, they wanna work and research in a company or on their own without doing higher studies.

These learners who want to do “non-PhD” research do not have access to a good research guide except for very few, highly unlikely cases who can join few good companies which have good researchers as a guide and also where their interest aligns with the company goal.

Let’s talk about importance of a research guide. Without a research guide, you can get stuck in gaps, and it becomes harder to fill the gaps in your understanding. This will become clear in following sections. A good research guide can help you in that. Without research guide, a part of your brain can become guide, and it just guide you to do simple stuff, and won’t let you put efforts where required. And since you are not good at research, therefore this brain guide is not a good research guide for you. If there is a good real research guide and you trust him/her then putting efforts for you become natural, you can put efforts effortlessly.

How can one become an AI master or a great AI researcher without a good research guide who can guide them. Learners have access to plethora of learning resources available online in exchange of inexpensive internet. X learners who plan to become “non-PhD” AI researchers can naturally learn from these available learning resource and become an AI master successfully. But unfortunately learning and mastering from these available learning resources for Y learners is not natural which is a similar situation we mentioned in our analogy in the “Introduction” section.

So, therefore we need similar “help” for Y learners in the context of AI. So that curiosity is the only prerequisite which means nothing but every learner should be able to master AI naturally. This is our goal and we will talk about it in detail in next and in upcoming sections.

To create such a help, we need to know what our learners are already good at. We are assuming that learners are already good at school-level maths. This is a very weak assumption and there are so high chances of it being true that we can safely call it a “fact”. And for the rare case, where a learner is not even familiar with school-level maths can learn school maths “easily” because it is intuitive. There are also high chances that many of the learners are only good at school level maths because maths beyond school-level maths is unintuitive and difficult. Curiosity of all learners can be equally high but state of intelligence can not be same.

To make sure that curiosity is the only prerequisite to take “help”, we will be using this fact. By curiosity as only prerequisite, we ensure inclusivity because all learners are curious (this is the definition of “learners”) but not necessarily intelligent.

Goal

Goal is to create a help such that by using it any learner can master AI naturally where only prerequisite is curiosity.

Let’s break it. AI mastery is the output after mastering by taking this help.

There is some redundancy in our above statement describing goal. Help is for any learner means curiosity has to be the only prerequisite. Since all learners have curiosity to master AI, therefore all learners already satisfy the prerequisite of this learning resource.

And process of mastering by taking help should be natural or effortless. Since it is for any learner and a learner can have only curiosity and nothing else like intelligent. So, to ensure that every learner successfully master AI, a learner should be able to naturally master, i.e. without feeling effortfulness. So, there is no thought trying to stop them to master. Naturalness ensures that a learner who starts mastering, will persevere, won’t give up in between and successfully achieve it. More about “Why naturalness?” in one of later section.

Inspiration for such a goal came from Y learners. Such a way will greatly benefit Y learners while X learners will have small but non-zero benefit with respect to already existing learning resources. So, X learner do not care much for such a resource but Y learners care a lot. And since X learners are rare, this learning resource will cater majority of the learners.

How such help will help all kind of learners? Such help not only help in creating “non-PhD” AI researchers but also help all X and Y learners. E.g. Very few of the Y learner will like to join a top PhD programme, but they are either not confident about this or struggling in making a research profile. This will help them in that. Or for those who are not “learners” yet but wanna try it and see what it is like.

In following sections, we will first try to understand the goal in detail before moving to how to achieve it.

AI

By “AI”, we mean by all AI algorithms. And in the context of this blog, we not only mean by “AI algorithm” as a way to simulate intelligence (talked about it in one of previous blog titled “AI - Mathematical Formulation of Intelligence”), but actually we are using the phrase to represent any of the discoveries (research papers) in AI.

Let’s first talk about AI research. Technology research or AI research is about finding “logical” solutions to problems. Logical solutions are proposed by researchers in research papers and expands research community’s knowledge logically. “Logical” here is nothing but whatever they are proposing has to be newer i.e, different than proposals in existing papers and is either better or has the potential to be better than other existing solutions. Whenever some researcher’s paper is reviewed for publication in a conference or journal, it is checked that whatever the paper is proposing is logical or not.

There is always an algorithm along with solution in an AI research paper. Either solution is the algorithm itself or there is algorithm to support the solution. In any case, we are calling the algorithm an “AI algorithm” just because it is there in AI research paper.

If solution is AI algorithm itself then that algorithm is either intelligence-simulating algorithm (ex: new model, new loss, new optimiser etc.) or that algorithm is an improvement over existing AI algorithms (recursive definition). Improvement could either be in explanation, evaluation, efficiency or performance. Some examples of algorithms for explanation are: explaining a layer (like batch norm) or activation functions (like why relu over sigmoid) or optimisers (like why SGD generalise better than Adam in some cases) or why neural network can learn and generalise etc.

If solution is not algorithm itself but some theoretical findings, then in this case, algorithm is there to support the theoretical findings, i.e., algorithm is used to do experimentation to check whether theoretical findings are true or not by finding evidence. If true then to what extent it is true. We are focusing on algorithm because “mastering” it meaning including whole research paper and solution. This will get more clear in next section.

Depending on how new is the solution, it can be classified as iterative or novel research.

We will talk about how to do research in next section. Understanding how to do research will let us understand easily what we mean by “mastering” anything.

Now, let’s talk in detail about “AI algorithm”. Any AI algorithm is nothing but an advanced machine learning (ML) algorithm. ML is a way via computers can learn. “ML algorithm” is nothing but implementation of ML concepts. And any ML algorithm is nothing but an application or combination of high-dimensional (or “HD” for this blog) maths tools. High-dimensional is anything which is more than 1 dimensional.

Note:- Mathematics required to master ML and AI is Linear Algebra, Probability, Statistics, Multivariate Calculus, Optimisation etc. I have used the term “maths fundamentals” in my previous blogs to refer to this required maths. Here I will be using another term for “maths fundamentals”, which is “high-dimensional maths”. Both terms represent the same maths and can be used interchangeably. Not all but most of maths fundamentals is high-dimensional. “High-dimensional” term is just used to emphasis the main difficulty in mastering maths fundamentals.

Basic ML algorithms are simple algorithms like linear regression, logistic regression, shallow neural networks etc. They do not simulate human-like intelligence but they have very useful many real-world applications like house price predictions, forecasting etc. If one is not interested in their application then still one should understand these algorithms because they can help to easily understand ML concepts.

Advanced ML Algorithms or “AI algorithms” are ML algorithms, so same ML concepts are used. Advanced ML algorithms are similar to basic ML algorithms. The only difference is that there is a lot more use of HD maths in AI algorithms. Because AI algorithm implement human-like learning and simulate human intelligence which is more complex than simple problems solved by basic ML. Complexity which AI algorithm deals with is high dimensional highly nonlinear functions whose either input or output or both lies in HD spaces. These HD spaces can be of images, text, speech, music, videos, etc. To deal with such complex functions, one need to use a lot more HD maths. More use of HD maths tools will be like more application of matrix multiplication (E.g., in deep neural networks), use of function approximation which is taylor approximation (E.g. for approximating loss surface for analysis or for second-order optimisation which involves hessian) or use of multivariate normal distribution for approximating high-dimensional probability distribution etc.

There are only few parts of high dimensional maths for which we can draw analogies with 1 dimensional or 2 or 3 dimensional maths and hence they are intuitve. Rest (majority) of parts of high dimensional maths are highly unintuitive, which makes it difficult to grasp, which requires significant efforts to understand.

How research is done?

Note:- This section may get heavily edited in later versions.

In this section, we will talk about how research is done to better understand what we mean by mastering a topic.

To solve a problem and find a logical solution, a researcher has to first choose some tools. Depending on how much new or different the solution a researcher want, we will chose the tools for solving. Choosing the tools means assuming that these are the only [best?] tools available to solve the problem. And we have to find the better solution given these tools.

More complex the tools we choose, more closer we are to logically solve the problem. More complex the tools, more heavylifting is outsourced to the tools and we have to only do small tweaks. More complex the tools we choose, more potential other complex tools we are discarding. More complex the tools we choose, more cons it will have along with more pros because finding the ideal tool out of exponentially large number of all possible complex tools is very difficult. Hence, more complex the tools, more our assumption is strong and less of it is true. Hence, more complex the tools, lesser the solution is logical - less new as well as less better. Less new because with only small tweak we are able to get to the solution. Less better because of only small tweak, we are only iteratively improving the solution, hence only able to suppress the cons little bit and not entirely.

More simpler choosen tools are, less weaker the assumption is. Meaning, less number of total tools exist, so more chances that we are picking the ideal tool or whatever tools which are picked they are closer to being ideal. Which means, we are more away from solving the problem, bigger solution space, more control we have in our hand to find more logical solution, more control we have in our hand to fix cons of existing complex tools. Because we know the existing complex tools available and their cons, so keeping this in mind, we can first find different and better complex tools for our problem using simpler tools. And then using better complex tools to solve the main-problem in more logical way.

At the simplest level, very few tools exist and all are ideal, perfect tools with no scope of improvement, meaning these are the tools which is going to solve any problem perfectly and lead to most logical solution ever exist. If tools are simplest then we are solving the problem from first principle because then we are not assuming, we are sure that this is the only way to solve the problem logically and therefore solving in most logical way possible.

More simpler the tools, we are more closer to solving the problem from first principle. But at the same time, it becomes difficult to find the logical solution. But even closer to solving from first principle is enough, i.e., using simpler tools and not simplest, is enough. Below even if a problem is solved from simpler tools and not simplest, we will call it “solving from first principle”. In other way, by solving from first principle, we mean that we are not using the most complex tools.

[continuum between applied to fundamental] In research, every paper do choose some tools and then by using it, researchers propose something new on top of it. Depending on the level of complexity of the choosen tools, the “assumption” as explained above will be weaker or stronger and hence the corresponding paper could be part of “fundamental” research or be part of “applied” research.

Applied research is application specific where researchers want to solve a given real-world problem in best way possible from whatever complex tools available. So, they will choose most complex tools which are available like transformer, a complex neural network and assume that they are good enough in themselves and uses it to solve some real-world problem like disease diagonosis.

On the other hand, researchers in fundamental research do not focus on solving any problem from given most complex tools. Rather, they try to come up with better complex tools so that any real-world problem can be solved in a more logical way (more newer and more better). That is, they try to solve a problem from first principle by choosing simpler tools. E.g. they will not assume that current transformers are good enough, they will rather just assume that neural network, a less complex tool or a simpler tool, are good and try propose something which improves upon current transformers. A even more fundamental research wont asssume that neural network are good and they will propose some alternative of neural networks. Some other fundamental research will assume neural network and but propose a totally different way of training them. More simpler the tools, more fundamental the research is.

How solving from first principle looks like? We first find the problem to solve. Let’s call it as “main-problem”. Then we decide what tools we are using and assuming that this is what we know as best available. Given these tools, we find the solution logically. And given these tools, solution is logical. But could have been more logical if tools were less complex.

AI Mastery

In this blog, AI mastery is nothing but able to do “great” AI research. So, a master in AI or “great” AI researcher is same thing.

To become a researcher, one has to first master community’s existing knowledge, so that one can extend community’s knowledge logically, i.e., find newer and better algorithms or algorithms which has potential to be better. And also to get inspiration about what problem to solve or how to solve or both. Mastering community’s existing knowledge is nothing but mastering existing AI algorithms. There is a dedicated section below about how one becomes a researcher after mastering enough AI algorithms.

There are lots of algos and one should master enough AI algorithms, so therefore one should first master a skill which lets you master any AI algorithm naturally”. Let’s call it “stage 1”. Reaching to stage 1 means one have mastered this skill.

After reaching stage 1, one can easily master existing community’s knowledge or AI algorithms. And after mastering enough AI algorithms, one will reach final stage where one is able to do great AI research. Let’s call the final stage “stage 2”.

Now let’s define “AI mastery” which is able to master any AI algorithm naturally and able to do great AI research.

How to master a topic?




===============================

===============================





===========================================================

[introducing “learning from first principle”]






Learning Resource or Ramp

[may be move it after the section “How to master a topic?”]

=============================


Going to Stage 1


======================================================




How a Y learner can learn naturally? Answer: Gentle Ramp

====================



“G-Ramps” to achieve the Goal

Note:- Mention that one do not even need to revise school-level maths. G-ramps should cover enough such maths so that one can revise it while going over a g-ramp.

=============================



In first principles understanding, we will be going only one level down, which will be enough to connect it to school-level maths. And this should make the ramp “smoother” than almost all the tutorials or blogs available on any topics.

Going to Stage 2

Note:- First draft

=====================



Conclusion

Some Extra Sections

Which are yet to be merged to main blog.

Who is this for?

How the “G-Ramps” would look like?

This is how it will look like:

How G-Ramps approach of learning/teaching is different than other learning resources?